VA Loans vs. Conventional Mortgages

Deciding between a VA loan or a conventional loan may seem easy. No money down, no mortgage insurance, a better interest rate — a VA mortgage wins hands down, right?

But when you consider things like the VA funding fee and perhaps putting enough money down on a conventional mortgage to forgo mortgage insurance, the choice may be more complex. And, some of the VA loan benefits, such as no minimum credit score and no maximum debt-to-income ratio, are often overstated.

Here are the factors to consider when deciding between a Department of Veterans Affairs mortgage or a conventional loan.

Property type

To start, the type of property you’re buying can be a primary factor in the VA-versus-conventional decision.

“The VA loan is for primary residence only,” says Donna Bradford, an assistant vice president of Navy Federal Credit Union. “Whereas a conventional loan can be used to purchase a primary [home], you can use it to purchase a second home — maybe a vacation home — or you can also use it to purchase an investment property, a rental property.”

Down payment

A major benefit of a VA loan is that no down payment is usually required. A lender may require money down if the purchase price of a property is higher than its current market value. That can happen in competitive housing markets with a multiple-bid situation.

Lenders offering conventional loans have traditionally preferred larger down payments, but these days, it’s easy to find conventional mortgages available with down payments as low as 3% — or even lower.

Fees

Next, there is the matter of fees.

A VA-insured loan requires a funding fee to help defray the costs of loans that default. That’s a one-time upfront charge that’s between 1.25% and 3.3% of the loan amount, depending on your down payment, length and branch of military service, and whether you have used your VA loan benefit before. The fee is often rolled into the loan amount, which makes your payment higher and adds to the interest you pay over the life of the loan.

Veterans who receive VA disability compensation are exempt from having to pay the funding fee, according to the Veterans Affairs department.

Mortgage insurance

If your down payment is less than 20%, a conventional loan will require private mortgage insurance, which protects the lender if you default on the loan. It can be a one-time charge paid at closing, an ongoing fee that’s built into your monthly payment, or a combination of both. That, and the amount you pay for PMI, varies with each lender. Depending on your credit score and the size of your down payment, PMI fees can range from 0.55% to 2.25% of the loan amount, according to Genworth and the Urban Institute.

VA loans don’t require mortgage insurance.

A down payment reduces but doesn’t eliminate the VA funding fee. However, with 20% down on a conventional loan (even less with some lenders — it’s 5% with Navy Federal, Bradford says) you won’t have to pay PMI.

Credit score standards

You may hear lenders — and the Department of Veterans Affairs — claim that VA-insured loans have no minimum credit score and no maximum debt-to-income ratio. That may be true as far as the VA is concerned, but not so much in the real-life world of lenders, according to Bradford.

“Most VA lenders use credit score benchmarks. That minimum will vary, but most VA-approved lenders are looking [for] at least 620,” she says.

In fact, the average FICO credit score for VA home purchase loans closed in 2016 was 707, according to mortgage industry software provider Ellie Mae. Conventional mortgages closed with an average 753 FICO score.

Debt-to-income ratios

VA marketing material says there is no maximum debt-to-income ratio, but it also says a “lender must provide compensating factors if the total debt ratio is over 41%.”

Greg Nelms, VA chief of loan policy, says those “compensating factors” include residual income. That’s the take-home income left at the end of the month after your new mortgage and all living expenses are paid.

Ellie Mae says the average debt ratio for VA purchase loans closed in 2016 was 40%. Conventional loans averaged a 34% debt ratio.

So yes, VA loans are easier to qualify for when it comes to debt and credit scores, but perhaps not as easy as VA promotional material may have you believe.

Mortgage rates

Another plus for the VA: It likely will have a lower interest rate than a conventional loan. For 30-year fixed-rate loans closing in 2016, VA loans had an average rate of 3.76%, compared with 4.06% on a conventional mortgage for the same term, according to Ellie Mae.

So, which mortgage?

“It comes to the point where it really is a personal decision,” Bradford says. You want to make a solid financial decision, as best you can, she adds.

VA Loans vs. Conventional Loans

  VA Conventional
Property type Financing for a primary home only Financing for a primary residence, second home or investment property
Down payment No down payment Some programs offer down payments as low as 3% or even lower
Fees Has upfront funding fee, which can be as low as 1.25% of the loan amount to as much as 3.3% (plus any fees are charged by the lender) No funding fee (but lender fees still may apply)
Mortgage insurance No mortgage insurance With a down payment lower than 20%, private mortgage insurance is usually required
Credit score No credit score requirement; however, lenders commonly look for borrowers with at least a 620 FICO. Average FICO score on loans closed in 2016 was 707. Credit score of 620 or higher is usually required, though this depends on the lender. Average FICO score on loans closed in 2016 was 753.
Debt ratio Average 2016 debt ratio: 40% Average 2016 debt ratio: 34%
Interest rates Generally lower than on conventional loans Tend to be higher than on VA loans

 

Hal Bundrick is a staff writer at NerdWallet, a personal finance website. Email: hal@nerdwallet.com. Twitter: @halmbundrick.

The article VA Loans vs. Conventional Mortgages originally appeared on NerdWallet.

There are no comments

Thank you! Your comment has been submitted and is awaiting approval.